• If you are having trouble changng your password please click here for help.

Question for coin collectors/ silver experts

Unless they are slabbed and graded by PCGS, NGC, or another reputable company determining condition is subjective and you won't get anywhere by stating your opinion on condition. I would only consider paying to have better dates graded that have the potential to be worth more if they grade out. There is a coin show monthly at the Marietta Hilton, next one is Feb. 10th.
 
Link below will give you melt value. If you want much $$$ beyond that, you will have to pay to have them graded or find a coin collector willing to pay extra for ungraded coins. It will happen, but might take some time.
https://coinvalues.com/silver

PS post your question in ODT Silver thread. There are several knowledgeable guys there, they might have more insight.
 
Coins dealers are a lot like car dealers only with less transparency. There are periodic price guides they use and one to which you can subscribe. That one is called the "gray" sheet. Consider it the retail price sheet. There is a "blue" sheet that lists the wholesale values but it doesn't circulate outside the industry. You'd have to polish up on your grading skills, learn the dates and mint marks that are more rare but once you did, you could zero in on a good price a little under the gray sheet pricing and try to sell it here or elsewhere as a win-win. You make a few dollars more, one or a few buyers pay a few dollars less for a must have...Any rare dates/mint marks in top condition would be worth considering for slabbing - having one of the professional services grade them and encase them in plastic. The slab will be worth more than you'll get without it.

I hope this helps...
 
I've also (not a collector or grader) had good luck culling key dates or rare mints, and selling them ungraded on ebay, junking the rest in lots. I just don't make any representation as to what I 'think' the coin might grade at. High def, high resolution pics will sell the coin to someone who might want to pay to have it graded and slabbed.
 
they aint worth much to collectors unless they are graded or the buyer intends on grading

otherwise they sell for the cull value from the big distributors. apmex has them for between 15 and 16 bucks in "cull condition" but this varies

also, some of those are real shiney but if they have been cleaned they also fit into the cull grade. id find out which years and mints were less prolific and consider sending them to a grading agency before selling
 
I acquired s couple hundred Morgan and Peace silver dollars and was curious to their approximate worth. They have been sitting in one of my safes for a few years and I have absolutely no interest in collecting coins. I also inherited several one ounce silver coins but those are much easier to find a value on.
Some of the Morgans are in rough shape but the majority of the Peace dollars are in excellent condition. What would be a fair price to ask as a flat rate to sell them all?
I would much prefer to own a few more firearms and several thousand more rounds of ammo when the economy collapses than silver coins.
I realize that there are numerous coin collectors on ODT, and I was hoping that they could give me an idea of how to convert my unwanted coins into firearms and ammunition.
Make me a offer I caint refuse
 
Back
Top Bottom