Craftta is right on with that goat glue, it's bad a@@. I use Bohning but any archery type glue imo will bond to the arrow shafts better than plain super glue.
http://www.bohning.com/store/adhesives.html
I started out with Muzzy and their great, but I've been using NAP Thunderheads for several years now and really like them. 3 blade 85 grain gives me enough speed on my Hoyt and does a great job putting down deer quick. Lots a good options out there.