• ODT Gun Show & Swap Meet - May 4, 2024! - Click here for info

German dagger real or replica

JohnnyPlant

Default rank 5000+ posts
Classy AF
140   0
Joined
Jan 17, 2013
Messages
5,816
Reaction score
6,586
Location
Woodstock
This was in father-in-law’s estate, with a verified 1914 Luger with original holster and an old appraisal letter. But I know there are way more replicas of these than real one so im reaching out to the collective think tank.
4EF82276-EEA6-4F31-B3AD-ABBD643E3F87.jpeg
9E920F0A-58CA-434D-8439-842C0767E535.jpeg
3862D09C-3908-45D4-A168-AB331CCC947E.jpeg
B33AE53F-0AF4-4BAB-BDA7-488914E09393.jpeg
30F3AFE4-F447-4211-8F08-FD018D17FF19.jpeg
9FB670BD-D2D0-4700-8AC4-CBCE35FFE645.jpeg
ED18BDC3-60F0-42A6-85D3-8F078F4AD374.jpeg
 
It looks "right" to me. ( that doesn't mean much BTW) if your FIL, acquired this in the 70's there is a pretty good chance that it might be real. The problem is that all of the orginal makers are still in Europe, and still have the orginal machines and dies, that were used in the 1940's. As this stuff started to demand premium prices, they took to remaking this stuff, selling it as orginal, found in a lost warehouse, etc. etc. It might sound weird, but sometimes if you pick it up, and look at it, it just feels "right" , and you have the sense that it's a real wartime production piece. Just my 2 cents.
 
It looks "right" to me. ( that doesn't mean much BTW) if your FIL, acquired this in the 70's there is a pretty good chance that it might be real. The problem is that all of the orginal makers are still in Europe, and still have the orginal machines and dies, that were used in the 1940's. As this stuff started to demand premium prices, they took to remaking this stuff, selling it as orginal, found in a lost warehouse, etc. etc. It might sound weird, but sometimes if you pick it up, and look at it, it just feels "right" , and you have the sense that it's a real wartime production piece. Just my 2 cents.
He has had it for a very long time and he was a smart man and definitely doesn’t have any reproductions or fakes that I know of. So it leads me to believe it’s real but I just don’t have the in-depth knowledge on these things like some other people have. I appreciate the input
 
Back
Top Bottom