The only holster I've used besides a MS was a Crossbreed. I'm not a fan of kydex...if the kydex was leather lined I might use that.
I was slow to come around but find that for real (almost) everyday use the kydex works best for me. There are long range days where my gun is drawn countless times so in addition to being a bit faster I really like the secure "click" sound of the gun being fully reinserted.
I also like the non-absorbent properties when it is in the mid to high 90's w/ 100% humidity & up against my skin.
However those are MY reasons relating to MY needs... doesn't mean that is what is best for everyone else.
There is nothing with a quality leather setup if you like it.
I am one of those people that does not feel that his friends & acquaintances have to wear the same underwear, socks, or holsters as I do.
To each his/ her own.
(
) 

