Yea I have had 4 of the taurus pt1911s the finish sucks. I had a rock Island cerakoted and it looked good. It realy depends on what kind of look your going for. Cerakote is going to be a flat and if you polish then blue it will be a gloss to high gloss. If you media blast and then blue it will be a mat finish as well. Cold bluing I have found to be almost a graphite color. But its very hard to get an even finish with cold blue. Or atleast it was for me.