Your problem is your inside sizing plug. It is .454" diameter for 45 Colt bullets. RCBS has very good customer service. Call them and tell them you need .451" inside sizing plug for 45 ACP bullets. I'd bet they would send you one free post paid. Good Luck and Happy Reloading
{most RCBS inside plugs have the diameter marked on the top
I have checked the sizing plugs on all the 45LC dies I have. None of them are marked with size only "RCBS 45 Colt" I checked them with my calipers and both are reading around .449-.450. I still must be doing something wrong. So from what you are saying, the problem lies within my sizing die, not my expanding or bullet seating die?