That update is interesting, I'm not sure why the link where I read it didn't have it updated. Thanks for the additional info though, I'll add it to my stockpile of info I may use one day. (which is about three warehouses worth at this point)I agree, if you are not in Grizzly country it is not too much of a concern as to the performance of the firearm you are caring.
The OP is actually going to Grizzly country and seeking an affordable handgun adequate to defend from a Grizzly charge.
The updated version of the article shared has more cases that have been found showing the viability of the handgun for bear defense. The largest sampling size is the 44 Magnum with 30 cases cited. It is probably an impossible task but it would be interesting to see what ammo is being used in each case. I know that one of the 9mm cases (Phil Shoomaker) was a 9mm using Buffalo Bore's 9mm load.
IMO if you are going somewhere there is no chance of a big bear encounter, carry whatever you want, or whatever you carry everyday. If you are going to grizzly country IMO the minimum would be 10mm in a semi and minimum 44 mag in a revolver.
Updated numbers on the previous article ( I think they updated it this year as more info was obtained). It is a good database that I hope they keep going as time goes on.
Handgun or Pistol Against Bear Attacks 104 cases, 97% Effective
In the latest update on how effective pistols and handguns are when used to defend against bears, 104 documented cases show a success rate of 97%.www.ammoland.com
I read that as well. The 45/70 with iron sights was one of the top rifle choices for big bear country. Scopes are nothing but a negative in those events.
