Wow...
Those are definitely keyholing. That first "After" pic looks like a pyramid! Glad you got it sorted. I'd have him check the baffles, too. In my mind, there's at least a strike or two going on in there...and I don't know if AAC will warranty it given that it was improperly seated.
I spoke with AAC last week as well and they're letting me send it back to be checked out. I can't "see" any baffle strikes, but that doesn't mean it wasn't happening. I'll give another update once everything gets sorted.