his numbers certainly say so
i think it's
rodgers
peyton
ryan
brees
i think it's
rodgers
peyton
ryan
brees
-
ODT Gun Show & Swap Meet - May 4, 2024! - Click here for info
is drew brees a top 3 qb?
- Thread starter rugerceltics13
- Start date
- Status
Are you serious............... He's most defiantly a top 3. Ryan is no where close to those 3.
You are referring to Matt Ryan right? the 1-3 Matt Ryan..........No matter how it is measured, Wins? Yards? TDs? SuperBowls? the other 3 are far better than Ryan, and I like the guy but right now no comparison.
You are referring to Matt Ryan right? the 1-3 Matt Ryan..........No matter how it is measured, Wins? Yards? TDs? SuperBowls? the other 3 are far better than Ryan, and I like the guy but right now no comparison.
yeah i'm serious. right now i think ryan is a better qb just by a little bit. not much. but why would you think ryan is not even close to top 3? is it cuz he hasnt' won a ring?
winning isn't a measure of talent all the time in my mind
winning isn't a measure of talent all the time in my mind
Read the post, Brees beats Ryan in all categories, all of them! On what measurement are you saying Ryan is better than Brees?
I think it's Peyton Brady Rodgers.
ryan manages the game better than brees. up until last year, brees has always had a very good defense to help bolster his stats. ryan has had bad defenses year in and year out and still manages to keep the falcons in contention
I say for this year so far:
Peyton Manning
Aron Rodgers
Philip Rivers
Drew brees
Matt Ryan
Andrew luck
Tony romo
Agreed. Finally Peyton has a good team around him and he's frickin unstoppable. Brady wins with scrubs or with stars. Those two are real close to number one and two...maybe inseparable. Rodgers? He has had some really bad games but is a solid number three. Brees at number four.
Who's next? Ryan? Flacco? Andy Dalton? Doesn't matter. There are four elite QBs and not a one wears a falcons jersey on Sunday (or Monday / Thursday).
I think ryan has the potential to get in that list but last night proved he's still a ways away. That fourth down throw behind rody white on 4th down, the interception with 8 mins left, and several other throws way over the heads of the receivers proved that. Arthur shouldn't have paid him that big money until he sniffs the Super Bowl.
brady? you mean the guy who hasn't been able to win more than 1 playoff game in the last 3 yrs?
Oops, I forgot Tom Brady. He's ahead of Andrew luck.
- Status
