is drew brees a top 3 qb?

[rugerceltics13]

Agreed. Finally Peyton has a good team around him and he's frickin unstoppable. Brady wins with scrubs or with stars. Those two are real close to number one and two...maybe inseparable. Rodgers? He has had some really bad games but is a solid number three. Brees at number four.

Who's next? Ryan? Flacco? Andy Dalton? Doesn't matter. There are four elite QBs and not a one wears a falcons jersey on Sunday (or Monday / Thursday).

I think ryan has the potential to get in that list but last night proved he's still a ways away. That fourth down throw behind rody white on 4th down, the interception with 8 mins left, and several other throws way over the heads of the receivers proved that. Arthur shouldn't have paid him that big money until he sniffs the Super Bowl.

flacco just threw 5 picks yesterday

 

[cpw006]

Agreed. Finally Peyton has a good team around him and he's frickin unstoppable. Brady wins with scrubs or with stars. Those two are real close to number one and two...maybe inseparable. Rodgers? He has had some really bad games but is a solid number three. Brees at number four.

Who's next? Ryan? Flacco? Andy Dalton? Doesn't matter. There are four elite QBs and not a one wears a falcons jersey on Sunday (or Monday / Thursday).

This if you're talking about last few years. And I'd take Eli in the last 2 minutes of the game to run down and score.

 

[rugerceltics13]

This if you're talking about last few years. And I'd take Eli in the last 2 minutes of the game to run down and score.

eli? u gotta be kidding right? eli is garbage. all he had to do was not lose the games for his defense

 

[cpw006]

eli? u gotta be kidding right? eli is garbage. all he had to do was not lose the games for his defense

I said last 2 minutes of a game, he's got some great comebacks.

 

[Jbum]

his numbers certainly say so

i think it's
rodgers
peyton
ryan
brees

I dis agree

Manning
Brady
Brees
Rodgers
Rivers

 

[Trader Jordon]

brady? you mean the guy who hasn't been able to win more than 1 playoff game in the last 3 yrs?

Ryan fits same category, and BTW Brees has never, had a good defense, ever! When your offense has a 3 TD lead it makes your defense better because of the predictability of the pass. The Saints have not had a good defense in years.

 

[rugerceltics13]

I said last 2 minutes of a game, he's got some great comebacks.

you mean like the come back where david wilson had to make a miraculous catch with his helmet cuz the thrown was so terribly out of reach? that comeback?

 

[Trader Jordon]

Are you measuring this season only or career?

 

[Jbum]

Ryan fits same category, and BTW Brees has never, had a good defense, ever! When your offense has a 3 TD lead it makes your defense better because of the predictability of the pass. The Saints have not had a good defense in years.

Ugh you are gonna take first place!!!!!!!!! Damn Sproles..................

 

[cpw006]

you mean like the come back where david wilson had to make a miraculous catch with his helmet cuz the thrown was so terribly out of reach? that comeback?

In six seasons Manning has 13 fourth quarter comebacks and 16 game-winning drives, including Super Bowl XLII. I had to look it up.