• ODT Gun Show & Swap Meet - May 4, 2024! - Click here for info

Diesel Truck Opinion

VindexInjuriae

Air Force Icon Supporter
Just one more.... Promise
44   0
Joined
Dec 7, 2010
Messages
283
Reaction score
131
Location
Manchester, GA
I always see posts on forums about "should I buy a diesel" and "which diesel is best". This is just my opinion, I'm not brand loyal, I've owned and driven diesels for 20 years, starting with NA 6.9s and running through just about every variation and model up to the DEF years.
Diesel motors are like 1911s.... not Glocks. They all have their quirks, each "brand" has it's upside and downside. They require more attention, more knowledge to maintain and more money, both upfront and long term.
Drivers that think they can buy a new diesel truck and drive 300k miles trouble free with only occasional oil changes are going to be sorely disappointed. Especially if they add a chip or tune without taking into consideration the extra wear the increased power adds to stock components designed for stock power.

My current fleet is a E99 F250 7.3 with 235k and an 05 Duramax with 150k. I do my own maintenance, all of it. I tow every day and drive a lot of miles. I research weak links and fix them before they become a problem. Oil and filter changes are regular, diesel is bought from known quality sources. As are parts.
My 7.3 is old, loud, outdated, slow as a tractor, and way underpowered compared to the new generation - but it works and roadside repairs are easy. It just doesn't quit.
My DMAX is fast, quiet, comfortable, and the Allison is a beautiful trans to tow with. Maintenance is harder, a 4 hour job on a 7.3 is 8 on a DMAX, generally speaking. Lots more widgets and wires and a totally different animal, but I like it.

Best advice I can give to a prospective owner is this: Find the truck you like, they all drive different. Research dedicated diesel forums for known issues for that model and decide if you're willing to add the repair costs to whatever budget you have to purchase said truck. If not, pick another one. Or research then drive.
Learn how to work on it yourself or find a good DIESEL shop before you need it. You will need it. Shade Tree Joe is not a diesel mechanic. Parts swapping can be very expensive for you. Just because the scanner says #8 injector is bad doesn't mean it is....
Avoid anything that looks like it's had a hard life, been abused, shows signs of bad leaks, has funky coolant, or evidence of power adders. A beautiful, new truck that Bubba "chipped" and ran on race tune with his stock trans.... is going to cost you.
Realize $29.95 oil changes don't exist for you anymore. More like $100+. Then add for fuel filters.
Realize the need for quality fuel is paramount to reliability, can't shop by price alone.
Realize any part specific to a diesel is more expensive. A $12 small block Chevy thermostat is $50+ on a DMAX... and it has 2 of them.
Realize insurance is usually more. 3/4 and 1 tons are typically more costly to insure.
Realize if you use it for your business you may fall into the 10k GVWR red tape nightmare that is the DOT & FMCSA.
Realize people lie on the Internet. Nobody is getting 25mpg in a 1 ton dually towing 10k at 80 mph. I average 9mpg in the 7.3 and 14.5 in the DMAX towing roughly 7k every day, mix driving. That's hand calculated mileage over tens of thousands of miles.

Realize they're just like a 1911.... properly maintained, rigorous service, and preventive maintenance will give you a dead nuts reliable work horse. Anything less, it may or may not work when you need it and will undoubtedly be an expensive source of frustration to deal with along the way.

Just my opinion.... Feel free to chime in ;)
 
I will never understand the point of owning a diesel if you don't need one... I wish I could drive a regular 1500 crew cab!

Because you can't "roll coal" in a 1500!!! I see 16-18 year old kids all the time in 2013+ diesels with lifts, tuners, over sized tires and wheels and it's just as bad as getting your daughter a little sports car.
 
i would like a newer one as my next vehicle but with the BS of the DEF & now higher fuel costs of diesel over Unleaded I'm unsure and will cross that bridge when it comes to it
for now my 2wd avalanche gets really good gas mileage for its size
My 7.3 is unstoppable 390k here wish they still made that engine

Im leaning towards a Cummins Dodge if i get another diesel
 
Back
Top Bottom