Who is the greatest NFL player of all time?

[WallsGa]

Walter Payton
LT
Anthony Munoz
Jim Brown
Joe Montana
Barry Sanders

 

[JWC]

In my opinion, Jim Brown is the best football player I ever saw. Not the best person, don't particularly like his views on certain issues, but in my mind the best football player. Of course, just my opinion and what do I know.

 

[GFB]

I would vote Lawrence Taylor. He was an unstoppable force. He caused fundamental changes to the way football is played even to this day.

 

[fslc94]

Peyton is not top 10, he has his personal records that are being broke and he suxed in the playoffs.

 

[MRH]

All great players on the list. Being somewhat biased towards defense, I believe Deion Sanders belongs there, along with Dick Butkus. Those two defensive players could almost single handedly dominate an entire side of the field. More than Reggie White, IMO, and yes, even more than LT.

 

[Mirvin 264]

Bo Jackson, just too bad he didn't get to play long enough to really show out.

 

[WallsGa]

Neon Deion was so good that teams wouldn't even throw to his side of the field. But, I like my cornerbacks to tackle. I would take Champ Bailey or Darrell Green over Deion.

 

[Trader Jordon]

TB12

9 Superbowl Appearances and 6 rings over a 20 year span.

I wonder if Jerry Rice would have been that good without the Stickem

I wonder if Tom Brady would have been that good without cheating?

 

[coach482]

Gale Sayers, Howie Long, Mean Joe Green

 

[Trader Jordon]

Peyton is not top 10, he has his personal records that are being broke and he suxed in the playoffs.

He sucked in the playoffs, but had a better record vs Brady in the playoffs? Hmmmm

Manning beat Brady 3 out of 5 playoff games.