Need opinions on red dot selection

[greg vess]

Does strike fire have an etched reticle? I thought that was the spitfire

Yeah I didn't see that in the Strikefire info either when I got reading up more.

 

[FreedomUSMC]

If you do have an astigmatism, you may need a prismatic optic.

Primary Arms The SLx 1x MicroPrism​

Vortex Spitfire 1x

PRIMARY ARMS SLX COMPACT 1×20​

Atibal SAP 1x Micro Prism

Athlon Midas TSP1

 

[DirtySouth]

Primary Arms SLx MD-25 Rotary Knob 25mm Microdot - ACSS-CQB Red Dot

Details“2021 Industry Choice Awards Red Dot Optic of the Year”After rigorous field testing, this optic has been given a Silver-tier rating by the National Tactical Officers Association.This Primary Arms red dot sight is part of the SLx optics line. SLx optics built their reputation for...

www.primaryarms.com

This is the one I am looking at.

That is a red dot so you’ll get the starburst effect more than likely. You need a prism optic with the etched reticle like the one below. It is what I have and there is no starburst effect.

Primary Arms SLx 1X MicroPrism™ Scope - Red Illuminated ACSS Cyclops Reticle - Gen II

DetailsAfter rigorous field testing, this optic has been given a Silver-tier rating by the National Tactical Officers Association. This Primary Arms MicroPrism is part of the SLx optics line. SLx optics built their reputation for innovation, reliability, and value. All SLx optics undergo...

www.primaryarms.com

 

[cmshoot]

Some folks with astigmatism can run a RDS just fine……..I do. I own a bunch of Aimpoint Micros and have no issues using them.

There are “levels” of astigmatism. Most folks with astigmatism can run a RDS, but some cannot.

As with most things, don’t let cookie cutter answers make your decision for you.

 

[above_all]

Primary Arms is running their 12% off sale today.

https://www.primaryarms.com/

 

[ReservoirDawg10]

I have astigmatism. I don't need prism sights. There are trade-offs going with a prism sight over a red dot or holographic sight that I find more degradation than some starburst.

 

[Scraper]

I have astigmatism and run an Aimpoint PRO without issue. If I get lazy and stare at the dot, it turns into a comet. Maintaining a target focus and subconsciously superimposing the dot negates any comet effect, or at least my perception of it.

You lose the ability to run BUIS with a prism mounted as well, even a 1x. A QD mount makes that a moot point though.

 

[Mrs_Esterhouse]

I have astigmatism and run an Aimpoint PRO without issue. If I get lazy and stare at the dot, it turns into a comet. Maintaining a target focus and subconsciously superimposing the dot negates any comet effect, or at least my perception of it.

You lose the ability to run BUIS with a prism mounted as well, even a 1x. A QD mount makes that a moot point though.

This. The Aimpoint PRO is the way to go.

 

[opps]

I have tried them all. Have many Aimpoint models. Have two of these PA.
one in 5,56 and one in 9mm. All are good to go. I have not tried the lower end SLX.

 

[Burdy]

Good Lord. Quit telling people you can see your Aimpoint just fine with your astigmatism. Everyone has different eyeballs and astigmatisms affect everyone differently. Some can see red dots fine, some cannot. Some can see holographic sights better, some cannot. It will depend on YOU. If you want a perfect circle you will need something with an adjustable diopter or you will have to keep looking through optic after optic until you find one that works.

Typically, larger MOA dots will be cleaner for you. For me, with astigmatism, I need to get up around 6 MOA for a clean circle. Your mileage may vary. With that being said, I still run red dots and holographic sights because while it's not perfect, I would rather have the speed in certain instances. I can take a 6 MOA dot, and still make hits on face-sized targets at 100 yards with no magnification. You just need to figure out what your use case is but I wouldn't let a little starburst or funky shape dot automatically kill it as an option for you.